
Originally Posted by
UTF
Of the 20, I only enjoyed about 4. Most of the clips aren't that funny to me. Yeah, they may be fitting and show parallels, but if the scene you're referencing isn't comedic to start (if it's a TV or film quote), or if the footage scenes you choose to pair with it aren't comedic to start, it's probably not going to be funny.
Hearing 'Who Let the Dogs Out' with some scenes of dogs, yeah, I get it. But are the dogs doing anything funny? They're just sitting there. Is anything funny happening around the dogs, or are people reacting to the dogs in a funny way? Not really, it was just the dogs being their on screen.
Hearing the 'mole' scene from Goldmember featuring a character that does have a pronounced mole on them. Yes, the connection's been made. Was the audio funny to start? I think it was. Are the characters assigned to the quote recreating the scene effectively? Yeah, I think they are. Are the characters doing funny things or reacting humorously? Well yeah. The character reactions are funny and manage to recreate the scene you're pairing. Well done.
I don't mean to sound like a dick, I just feel that a lot of the clips are just not funny. They may have a good connection to both sources and be edited together nicely, but unless there's humor to start, it's not gonna be funny. That's just my opinion.