Unofficial Petition Regarding Quality Control of AMV Minis

[jinzo64]

I don't mind being told about flaws as long as it's constructive.
but when the people reveiwing your entries come out with stuff like.
Erm Not that good, It doesn't realy help.

[thedarkmessenger]

Another reason we don't need Chewi as a judge anymore: "It's decent"

[HaarTheDragonlord]

^I remember Panda and Zuii making a joke about making a drinking game out of every time Chewi says "I could go either way"

I don't mind being told about flaws as long as it's constructive.
but when the people reveiwing your entries come out with stuff like.
Erm Not that good it doesn't realy help.

I agree that criticism needs to be constructive. At the same time, I believe that people shouldn't be over the top in their critiques. I recall a guy making a joke about some video of mine just being "ZOMG FIGHTS" and he was right, but I thought to myself "check out the ego on this nigga." Got a laugh out of that, though.

[jinzo64]

^I remember Panda and Zuii making a joke about making a drinking game out of every time Chewi says "I could go either way"


I agree that criticism needs to be constructive. At the same time, I believe that people shouldn't be over the top in their critiques. I recall a guy making a joke about some video of mine just being "ZOMG FIGHTS" and he was right, but I thought to myself "check out the ego on this nigga." Got a laugh out of that, though.

A middle ground when critising somthing can be hard to do.
I guess I'll find out first hand how hard constructive critism can be when I start excepting submissions for AMV Hell Spinoff.

[HaarTheDragonlord]

In my opinion, it's not really too difficult. I attempt to judge things with an even hand when reviewing AMVs. I only really "attack" flaws once I've pointed them out to the person in question several times. Of course, by that point, I've usually given up on the person.

[jinzo64]

I guess it depends on the maturity of the person doing the judging.

[HaarTheDragonlord]

I'm not sure if "maturity" is the right word for this situation. Maybe "tact".

[jinzo64]

I guess Tact Would have been a better word in this instance.

[HaarTheDragonlord]

Maturity is pretty relevant when we're referring to the people being judged, though.

[jinzo64]

I guess that's true.
Tact from the judge and materity from the subbmitters.

to be honest it's very rare that theres poor video or audio quality in the amv's it just some times the amv's have poor concepts and just seem to drag.

[HaarTheDragonlord]

I notice clips having poor editing a lot of the time, in addition to the issue of dragging out and having poor video quality.

[jinzo64]

I notice clips having poor editing a lot of the time, in addition to the issue of dragging out and having poor video quality.

I'll agree with editing quality and the issue of dragging out but I personally noticed poor video quality.
maybe i'm wearing slightly rose tinted glasses.