[Enkim]

http://pl.youtube.com/watch?v=F4buYYlcVZQ&eurl=http://pl.youtube.com/my_videos_edit2

[1337uvis]

sorry, but this just sucks. The songs we all heard from amv hell already, so nothing new there, and the scenes from the animes looks just... random, like you scrolled to it and said "yeah, that'll work".
So yeah, that's a 3/10 in my book. That 3 is for the effort required to make a 3 minute amv :)

[Useful]

sorry, but this just sucks. The songs we all heard from amv hell already, so nothing new there, and the scenes from the animes looks just... random, like you scrolled to it and said "yeah, that'll work".
So yeah, that's a 3/10 in my book. That 3 is for the effort required to make a 3 minute amv :)

That's not nice. And not entirely true, either. During the verses, he purposely looked for scenes that matched the description. And the syncing was honestly pretty good. The main problem was the chaos. This song works better with a slower approach, except for on the guitar solo. If it had LESS stuff in it, it would be a lot better. Especially take out Eva and Ah! My Goddess because they emphatically don't have a sharp dressed guy in them, and have nothing to do with the song. At all. Same goes for Love Hina. The other issue I saw was with lack of attention to the actual meaning of the song. The best AMV's comentate or parallel the song to some degree, and this AMV would benefit hugely from that. I'd say focus on Bleach or something like that, and it would be a lot more effective.

[1337uvis]

syncing is something you can see in here: (although German is mandatory in order to understand)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4375MDu-xl0

[Useful]

syncing is something you can see in here: (although German is mandatory in order to understand)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4375MDu-xl0

I know almost no German but it was very obvious that the syncing there was amazing. I'm not saying that his was VERY good syncing, I'm saying is was okay.

[1337uvis]

now okay, i must give him that, there was some degree of syncing and yes, i've seen alot worse... okay, i guess i can raise that to 6/10 for his amv ;)

[Useful]

now okay, i must give him that, there was some degree of syncing and yes, i've seen alot worse... okay, i guess i can raise that to 6/10 for his amv ;)

That's about what I was thinking, really. A 5 or a 6 out of 10. I hope he comes back and reads this. I'd feel really silly if he didn't :P.

[1337uvis]

lol, that would be awkward :D how much you give on the hellsing one? You're the 2nd person that has actually seen it :D

[Enkim]

One important thing is fact that I from poland ;] and I have little trouble with difficult words at yours post... but i don't give up ;p
I know yours opinion about this AMV and what is badly in this AMV (all is wrong?)

[1337uvis]

Hi there neighbour, I'm from Lithuania ;) your amv would be a 7/10 for sure if the screens didn't change so quickly, it goes too fast for the song :) then remove the anime's that don't have a "sharp dressed man" and your 8/10 :) and that's good :)

*oh, and feel free to jojn our discussions in the off-topic section, it might seem scary now, but spend a week here and you'll feel just like home ;)

[Useful]

lol, that would be awkward :D how much you give on the hellsing one? You're the 2nd person that has actually seen it :D

Did you make it? Because it's quite good :D. And if it is, (or even if it isn't) what's the song about? I'd like to know.



One important thing is fact that I from poland ;] and I have little trouble with difficult words at yours post... but i don't give up ;p
I know yours opinion about this AMV and what is badly in this AMV (all is wrong?)

Yeah, I picked the "Polish" thing up from your profile. You two both know the area very well because you live in it, so I had no chance of keeping up.

And to answer your question, it's too fast and has a lot of stuff that doesn't have to do with the song. Basically, you put too much into an AMV that could have been quite good.

Question: Do you want me and Lietuvis to help you with your grammar actively? Like, tell you what's wrong with how you say things in English?

[1337uvis]

Question: Do you want me and Lietuvis to help you with your grammar actively? Like, tell you what's wrong with how you say things in English?

...for only $9.99 you could... LOL ;D just reminded me of that, hilarious :D
oh and yea i made it myself :D the song is "engel" by rammstein. It's pretty much... wait, let me listen again :D
"He who spends his time on the Earth well, he after death an angel will become... the heaven ask you then, why can you not see them? ...*chorus* it's when the people go to sleep, can you us in Heaven see... we have fear and are alone...*/chorus*... I FOR SURE AN ANGEL WILL NOT BECOME!...whistling...I FOR SURE AN ANGEL WILL NOT BECOME!"

[Useful]

oh and yea i made it myself :D the song is "engel" by rammstein. It's pretty much... wait, let me listen again :D
"He who spends his time on the Earth well, he after death an angel will become... the heaven ask you then, why can you not see them? ...*chorus* it's when the people go to sleep, can you us in Heaven see... we have fear and are alone...*/chorus*... I FOR SURE AN ANGEL WILL NOT BECOME!...whistling...I FOR SURE AN ANGEL WILL NOT BECOME!"


Most excellent. A 9/10, indeed. If you made it so that only Seras was shown during the female voice part, that would give it another .5 at least.

[1337uvis]

Weirdly i actually wanted to do that with the part where she sits on the roof but then decided against that :D